A Spoiler Free Reread Review
If you are planning to purchase this book, please do so used in order to curb J.K. Rowling's spending on her transphobia.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is my favorite of the Harry Potter books, full stop. This review is a reread review but also specifically for the Jim Kay Illustrated Edition. This time around, I’m going to be trying to focus a bit more on reviewing Prisoner of Azkaban from the lens of it being illustrated. That said, I am absolutely in love with the cover! The contrast of the emerald green lettering against the indigo background and Knight Bus is just beautiful. I could happily just stare at this cover for a while.
I am also strangely in love with the inside cover illustration of Azkaban. I like the touch of the wrecked ships along the coastline. I also love that the Azkaban motif if carried through the title, copyright, and content pages. It’s way more beautiful than Azkaban deserves.
Honestly, the illustration of Aunt Marge in her swelled state is really disturbing and might haunt my dreams. Do not like.
Love the tile designs in chapter 4. They manage to be pretty cute. Also the two page spread for the Magical Menagerie shop is fascinating.
“Talons and Tea Leaves” was the first chapter for Harry Potter I remember reading. It had been published in Disney Adventures magazine ahead of the Prisoner of Azkaban book release. I remember it being much more atmospheric than it is when I read it now. Possibly to do with some of the illustrations Disney added. The doily motif used in this version of the book, however, doesn’t lend itself well to the atmosphere or the chapter, even if it is easy enough to read through. “Talons and Tea Leaves” does contain my favorite illustration, though. Jim Kay’s hippogriffs are absolutely gorgeous; fully deserving of their two-page spread. All the hippogriff illustrations are gorgeous. I especially love the background details in the Buckbeak portrait in chapter 14.
The illustration of Crookshanks and Scabbers is fantastic. Really captures Crookshank’s menacing look. As a veteran Harry Potter fan it is, of course, absolutely hilarious to me how Scabbers looks so terrified of him.
The grindylow two-page spread is impressive. Makes me wish it was included in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. Gorgeous and well detailed. The Werewolf page is less impressive. Between this illustration and the movie version, it’s super easy to tell a real wolf from a werewolf. Much rolling eyes.
The Marauder’s Map illustration is much more in line with what I’ve always envisioned as opposed to the movie version. I LOVE all the little details you can read if you squint. So cool.
So… butterbeer. Introduced in this book, so it makes sense Harry wouldn’t have had it before. However, if Fred and George can sneak down to Hogsmeade whenever they like and have brought butterbeer back before… which I assume they would have and do in this book… then why is it so odd to Lupin that Harry gets all excited about it. I doubt James and them wouldn’t have snuck butterbeer into the castle given the opportunity. Just a weird bit of retconning silliness I noticed.
I am in love with the tortoise teapot at the head of chapter 16. Love it, love it, love it. The greenhouse in the same chapter is wildly eccentric.
The Servant of Lord Voldemort contains the most menacing portrait of Snape I’ve ever seen. He looked unhinged… which he probably was in that moment, the git. The portrait of Peter is also terrifying, though for different reasons.
So yes, I am still very much in love with Prisoner of Azkaban. The illustrated version definitely enhanced the reading experience. 10/10, will probably reread this version again. And open it just to stare at the pretty pictures.