Take a Thief by Mercedes Lackey

A Spoiler Free Review

Take a Thief was honestly a lot of fun. I’m not sure I have too many deep thoughts about it, though. Skif was a fun protagonist to get to know and see grow. I honestly thought he was a lot older than he was while the whole stalking Jass thing was going on. It’s really no surprise that he came across as older, given what he’d been through and, as Alberich observes, had his childhood basically stolen.

That said, I don’t really need my main characters to be put-upon orphans. This is not a trope I enjoy very much and I don’t really think it does much for their character except to make them less likely to sniff at a bit of hardship. I mean… I guess it makes them a little more interesting than rando middle-class kiddo or the “I’m so spoiled everything shocks me” type… but… I dunno. Don’t know why the pair of kid main characters up til now in the chronology have had to be super destitute orphans. All that said, I do actually like Lackey’s world-building through and around Skif. I can really feel how gross the tavern is, how oppressively hot his room next to Jass is, and how disgusting that blanket at the end was.

However, I honestly find reading the “gutter speak” or whatever quite annoying. It was annoying when Mags (Collegium Chronicles and The Herald Spy) was speaking in it throughout his run and it’s annoying now with Bazie and Skif.

Speaking of, it is very clear that Mags is a pale imitation of Skif. Skif has infinitely more personality and feels much more real than Mags ever did. Skif fits better into the world he inhabits and isn’t just constantly referring to past hardships as though they’re a personality trait.

But yeah, aside from all that, I did really enjoy Take a Thief. It was interesting to see Alberich from an outside angle and know that it was Alberich even if Skif had no clue. I also actually enjoyed Skif’s spy stuff… mostly because it wasn’t referred to as such and was the thieving aspect of his life.

Very much looking forward to the next part of my Valdemar journey with Heralds of Valdemar. I have definitely read the next three books, so it'll be interesting to get to know Talia all over again... and maybe figure out why I definitely seem to remember Lord Orthallan being a baddie.